Who is tkin of carrick compared to orher midfielders like iniesta, xavi, alonso, lampard, yaya toure, david silva, schwazteinger, modric, etc, forget it carrick is a midiocre compared to other big team midfielders get rid of him we need players who can motivate others on the field of play; we need drivers of the game not stagnant players like carrick; mikel; etc: we need players wit energy: tell me which game or match carrick has single handedly won for united? None. Not carrick will be considered in a team coached by morinho; guardiola; simeoni; ancelloti; capello. In just a litle time blind and felliani has won us matches; therefore i say no to carrick he is too slow doesnt dribble no shot cant drive with the ball; infact carrick is made for d midtable teams: